How to Compare AI Search Optimization Tools: 5 Criteria That Matter
Dozens of platforms now promise to track your brand in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini. Their dashboards look alike; their numbers don’t. Here are the questions to ask vendors so you compare what actually matters.
Tristan Berguer
Co-founder, Atyla
The short answer
To compare GEO tools, look at five things: where the data comes from (how many real answers, collected how), engine coverage and frequency, a margin of error next to every number, actionability (audit, plan, measured impact) and price at equal volume. During the trial, open the raw answers behind a number. If you can’t, you can’t verify anything.
Your SEO tools (Semrush, Ahrefs) still matter, and they’re adding AI modules. But an AI answer isn’t a results page: it changes from one run to the next and cites third-party sources. These five criteria work for judging any tool, ours included.
1. Where the data comes from
Almost every tracking tool works the same way: it asks AI assistants questions and analyzes the answers. The difference is in the details. An assistant queried through its API can answer differently from the app your customers use, a badly written system prompt can push the model to name more brands than usual, and a question asked from another country returns different results.
Questions to ask the vendor:
- “Can I read the timestamped answers behind every number?”
- “Do you query the AI through its API or the consumer app? With what instructions?”
- “Which country and language are the questions asked from?”
- “Is your methodology public?”
Analyzing the AI crawlers (GPTBot, PerplexityBot, ClaudeBot) that visit your site is a different measurement, useful but distinct: it proves your pages get read, not that you get cited. Profound, Otterly.AI and Qwairy offer it as a module; Atyla integrates it through its partner Senthor.
At Atyla: every number opens onto the real, timestamped answers. Most assistants are queried through their API with a neutral instruction that only sets the country and language; for Gemini, Atyla reads the answer from the consumer app. It’s all documented on our methodology page.
2. Engine coverage and frequency
List the assistants your buyers actually use, then check which ones are included in the plan you’re considering and which cost extra. The differences are large: Otterly.AI includes ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot and Google AI Overviews from its Lite plan but charges extra for Gemini and Claude; Qwairy lists a very long set of engines on every plan; Semrush’s AI Visibility Toolkit tracks your prompts in ChatGPT and Google AI Mode.
Frequency matters too. AI answers shift from day to day, so a monthly snapshot can’t show a trend. Daily, or at least weekly, tracking is the norm.
At Atyla: daily, on ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini with Starter; Claude, Mistral, Grok and Google AI Overviews are added with Growth. Copilot and Google AI Mode aren’t tracked today.
3. Margin of error and alerts you can trust
Ask the same assistant the same question twice and you’ll rarely get the same list of brands. So “34% of answers mention you” means little without the number of answers and a margin of error: next week’s 31% could be a real drop or just noise.
- Does the tool show a margin (a confidence interval) next to every rate?
- Do alerts (email, Slack, webhook) fire on real changes, or on every wobble?
- Is the headline score explained, or is it a score out of 100 with no published method?
At Atyla: every rate comes with its 95% confidence interval. A rise or drop is only reported when it falls outside the margin, and alerts (email, Slack, Discord, Zapier, webhook) follow the same rule.
4. From insight to action
Knowing you’re rarely cited isn’t enough. A good tool tells you who gets cited instead, which sources the AI reads, what to fix on your site and in what order, then whether the fix worked.
- Audit and action plan: are recommendations checked page by page and prioritized?
- Execution: page drafts, a writer’s brief, or an agent that applies fixes? Writesonic, AthenaHQ and GetMint, for example, lean into content creation.
- Measured impact: does the tool compare visibility before and after each action, with the margin?
- Perception: if how the AI talks about you matters as much as whether it mentions you, look for sentiment analysis (Meteoria, Writesonic on its Growth plan).
At Atyla: a weekly site audit checked page by page, a prioritized plan with “My week”, page drafts and writer briefs, before/after impact for every action, and an MCP server (Growth plan) so Claude Code, Codex or Cursor can fix the site. Atyla doesn’t do sentiment analysis.
5. Price at equal volume
Entry prices only compare at equal volume: number of tracked prompts, number of engines included, and frequency. Check the currency too, whether the price excludes tax, and whether it assumes annual billing. Finally, look at the trial terms: free or not, card or no card, and for how many days.
Entry plans compared (October 2026)
Entry plans checked on October 8, 2026 on each vendor’s official pages. Atyla is our product.
| Tool | Entry price | Prompts included | Engines included at entry | Trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atyla | €89/mo excl. VAT | 30, daily | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini (Claude, Mistral, Grok and AI Overviews on Growth, €199 excl. VAT) | 7 days, card required |
| Profound | On request | 50 during the trial, then custom | Trial: ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Overviews; up to 9 engines on Enterprise | Free, 7 days |
| Peec AI | Not shown on the public page | Not shown | Not broken down by plan | Not stated |
| Otterly.AI | $29/mo excl. tax | 15 | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot, AI Overviews (Gemini, Claude, AI Mode as add-ons) | Free, length not stated |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | $99/mo | 25 | ChatGPT, Google AI Mode | No trial |
| Scrunch | $300/mo ($250 billed annually) | 350 | ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Meta | 7 days, no card |
| Qwairy | €79/mo excl. VAT (€65 billed annually) | Up to 100 | Every listed engine on every plan (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Grok, Mistral, AI Overviews, AI Mode…) | Free plan, 120 credits, no card |
Volumes aren’t strictly comparable: “question”, “prompt” and “credit” mean different things at different vendors. For 13 tools in detail, see the best GEO tools in 2026.
Frequently asked questions
How do you compare AI search optimization tools?
Look at five criteria: where the data comes from (how many real answers, collected how), which AI engines are covered and how often, how reliable the numbers are (margin of error, alerts that don’t fire on noise), how the tool turns findings into action (audit, plan, measured impact), and price at equal volume. During the trial, ask to read the raw answers behind any number.
AI crawler analytics vs answer tracking: what’s the difference?
Answer tracking asks AI assistants questions and counts how often your brand is mentioned: that’s what your customers see. Crawler analytics reads your server traffic to see when GPTBot or PerplexityBot visit your pages: it confirms your pages are being read, not that you’re cited. They complement each other. Atyla does answer tracking and integrates crawler analytics from its partner Senthor.
Does a GEO tool replace an SEO tool?
No. Semrush and Ahrefs are still the right tools for keywords, backlinks and technical SEO. A GEO tool measures something else: what AI assistants tell your customers. They work best together, and several GEO tools, Atyla included, connect to Search Console and Google Analytics to tie both views together.
Should I avoid tools with “contact sales” pricing?
Not necessarily: enterprise plans are often quote-based, at Profound, Scrunch or AthenaHQ for example. But for a smaller team, public pricing makes like-for-like comparison possible. Also check the currency, whether prices exclude tax, and whether the headline price assumes annual billing.
Put Atyla through these five tests
Open any number and read the timestamped answers behind it. 7-day trial, card required, nothing charged before day 8, cancel in one click.